Highland Park Methodist Church has asked a Dallas County court to temporarily bar the United Methodist Church's Horizon Texas Conference from holding services under the name Highland Park United Methodist Church. The request follows an October vote in which more than 90% of participating members backed leaving the denomination.
The Dallas congregation dropped "United" from its name after the vote and continues to worship at its longtime home at Hillcrest Road and Mockingbird Lane. The conference maintains that the vote was invalid and is holding services under the former name at University Park United Methodist Church, a separate congregation.
In its request for a temporary restraining order, Highland Park says it used its former name for more than 50 years and argues that the conference's use of it has caused confusion among members and donors, according to The Christian Post, citing FOX 4.
The dispute has also left worshippers with two pastors leading services at different locations. Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. appointed the Rev. Andy Lewis to lead Highland Park and reassigned the Rev. Matt Tuggle. The church council said Tuggle would remain its senior minister and continue preaching at the Highland Park campus. Saenz arranged for Lewis and members who wish to remain with the denomination to worship at University Park while the case proceeds.
Highland Park leaders said 90.35% of the 4,775 ballots cast favored leaving the United Methodist Church. The church council set Dec. 1 as its target for completing the work it says is needed to formalize the separation.
The fight over the name grew out of a lawsuit the conference filed in August challenging changes Highland Park made to its governing documents in 2022. The conference alleges that the amended bylaws stripped references to the denomination and curtailed members' role in church governance. Highland Park countered that the changes were permitted under Texas law and said it continued participating in the denomination and making annual payments to the conference after adopting them. A bench trial in the underlying case is scheduled for October 2027.
Founded in 1916 as University Church, Highland Park reported about 15,000 members and average weekly attendance of more than 4,000 in 2024, according to denominational figures cited by The Christian Post. Former President George W. Bush attends the church and has voiced support for Tuggle and the congregation.
















