News

Liberty Counsel’s 2026 Christmas Shopping List Moves Barnes & Noble and Big Lots! to “Nice,” Best Buy to “Naughty”


Published: Nov 17, 2026 07:12 AM EST

Barnes & Noble and Big Lots! moved onto Liberty Counsel's Christmas "Nice" list this year, while Best Buy returned to the "Naughty" list. The Christian legal organization's annual guide, updated Nov. 11, placed 28 retailers on its "Nice" list and 18 on its "Naughty" list based on whether their seasonal promotions explicitly mention Christmas, The Christian Post reported.

Barnes & Noble earned its new ranking after Liberty Counsel highlighted the bookseller's "Merry Christmas" gift cards, along with its selection of Christian books and Christmas merchandise. Big Lots! moved up after featuring a Christmas graphic on a webpage promoting seasonal products.

Best Buy, which was on the "Nice" list in 2025, moved back to the "Naughty" list. Liberty Counsel pointed to the electronics retailer's "officially saving season" and "deals for every list" messaging and said references to Christmas were difficult to find on its website.

Costco, Hallmark, Hobby Lobby, Home Depot, Kohl's, Macy's, Target and Walmart were among the retailers that kept their "Nice" rankings. Bass Pro Shops, Dollar General and Dollar Tree also made this year's list. Gap, Nordstrom, Lord & Taylor, CVS Pharmacy and Walgreens were among the retailers that remained on the "Naughty" list.

The rankings are part of Liberty Counsel's 24th annual "Friend or Foe Christmas Campaign." The group is urging shoppers to consider where they spend their money during the Christmas season and to support retailers that name the holiday in their advertising. Liberty Counsel founder and chairman Mat Staver tied the shopping guide to the organization's broader effort to preserve a place for Christian symbols and themes in public Christmas celebrations.

The campaign also cites polling on how Americans prefer to be greeted. A December 2024 YouGov survey of 1,136 U.S. adults found that 65% preferred "Merry Christmas" to "Happy Holidays." A December 2022 Monmouth University poll found that 61% preferred "Merry Christmas," while 30% favored "Happy Holidays."